See - sc.judiciary.gov.ph/pio/news/2012/11/11071201.pdf
"x x x.
Pursuant to Article VIII, Section 9 of the Constitution, the' Judicial and Bar Council (JBC) has the honor to submit nominations for one (1) position of ASSOCIATE JUSTICE of the SUPREME COURT OF THE PHILIPPINES (vice Hon. Maria Lourdes P. ·A. Sereno who was appointed as Chief Justice on 24 August
2012), per the JBC Minutes of even date, as follows:
1. Carandang, Rosmari Declaro -7 votes
2. Leonen, Marvic Mario Victor F. -7 vot&s I
3. Lotilla, Raphael Perpetuo M. -7 votes
4. Reyes, Andres Jr. B. -7 votes
5. Reyes, Jose Jr. C. -6 votes
6. Tijam, Noel G. -6 votes
7. Diokno, Jose Manuel I. -5 votes
x x x."
